What is an Employee Ownership Trust? And other common questions.

From the mechanics of how they work to the tax breaks, here we answer some common questions about employee ownership trusts.

 

EOT - Basics

1. What is an Employee Ownership Trust or EOT?

Employee Ownership Trusts are a special business model introduced by the Government to incentivise employee ownership. Put simply, it’s an indirect model where owners sell their shares to an employee-owned trust, giving the EOT (as they’re often called) a controlling interest in the business. But what’s the incentive? Well, a more engaged and productive workforce for one. But if you’re thinking financially, employee ownership trusts also come with tax benefits for owners and employees.

2. Will an employee ownership trust work for any business?

One of the biggest inhibitors of employee ownership is the assumption you must be a business of the size or scale of John Lewis to benefit. This isn’t the case. There’s no typical headcount for EOTs and you don’t have to fall into a narrow shortlist of sectors. But it’s not the best option for every company, so get professional advice before you jump in. A good place to start is to read our employee ownership guide

3. Aren’t EOTs only for large businesses?

We’ve completed EOT deals valued at everything from a few hundred thousand pounds to more than a hundred million. The number of employees and turnover of a business are usually irrelevant to the decision to switch to this structure. The only real limitation with an EOT is the selling shareholders can’t make up more than 40% of the total workforce.

4. What are the tax benefits of employee ownership trusts?

Yes, what you’ve heard is correct – by selling to an EOT you qualify for two attractive, government-backed tax breaks. Firstly, the proceeds of the sale of shares to an EOT are exempt from capital gains tax. Secondly, when a company is owned by an EOT, it can pay annual bonuses of up to £3,600 to each employee free of income tax. There are a few tests and criteria you’ll need to meet to qualify for the tax breaks though, so get advice to make sure you comply.

To compare the benefits of an EOT compared to other employee-ownership structures, read our employee ownership guide

 

Business performance

1. Are employee-owned businesses as competitive as conventionally owned businesses?

Yes. Within our client base, the success stories are stacking up for employee ownership. And this is a common trend. Research by the Employee Ownership Association reports year-on-year an increase in sales and operating profits for employee-owned businesses.

2. Will an EOT structure make staff more productive?

The Employee Ownership Association reports a 5.2% increase in productivity for employee-owned businesses, double the UK average. More engaged, more innovative, more fulfilled – the positive cultural effects of employee ownership have a clear, favourable impact on employee output. This adds to the long-term value of converting to an EOT.

 

The transition to an EOT

1. Does employee ownership only come about when a business owner is looking to sell up?

Not always. It’s often a looming business sale that prompts a business owner(s) to consider an EOT as an option, but it doesn’t need to happen at the point of exit. Some business owners choose to transition to employee ownership long before they cut ties entirely. This allows them to secure the benefits of the model early – including the tax exemptions. There are also other circumstances leading to employee ownership. For example, it may be introduced to attract, retain and motivate talented people as a business grows or at the other end of the scale to aid recovery for distressed businesses.

2. How can employees afford to buy a company?

With a sale to a trust, employees make no financial contribution. Instead, present or future cash reserves (sometimes bolstered with additional debt finance) are used by the EOT to purchase the business from existing shareholders. The former owners are then paid from company profits, often spread out in instalments over a number of years.

3. Is an employee buy-out more complicated than other types of sale?

There’s less need for negotiation, so the deal process itself tends to be more straightforward. But EOTs come with their own challenges. Significantly, the governance and management implications can be complex. Using advisors with experience in forming EOTs can ease the process and reduce complications.

4. Is the transition to employee ownership a quick process?

With a robust communication plan, (we can help with this) the transition can be quicker than most other succession options. We have completed an EOT deal within two weeks of the first legal documents being issued, but you should allow three months for a timely and stress-free transition.

 

Professional advice

1. How can Legal Clarity help with setting up an EOT?

As your lawyers, we handle all the legal documents governing the sale. We’ll also help structure pricing provisions and buyer protections. So, very similar to a more run-of-the-mill trade disposal. But what’s different, is the deal process. With an EOT, it’s less about negotiations and more about the details of the deal structure. Our focus is on making absolutely certain the EOT is set up in the right way for you and your business, now and moving forward.

For an explanation of the difference options around employee ownership structures, read our guide.

2. What other professional advice will I need when transitioning to an EOT?

As well as legal advice, you’ll need specialist valuation and tax advice too. We can help you find the right partners.

 

Founders & selling owners

1. If I sell the company to employees, can I still get the right price for it?

Seeking an independent valuation gives existing shareholders and the acquiring EOT assurance of a realistic market value. And with no capital gains tax to be paid on any proceeds from the sale, this business model adds extra value to the transaction for selling owners.

2. Can existing directors or sellers be a trustee of the EOT?

Yes, to both. But there are implications you need to consider, including how you deal with any potential conflict. We’ll guide you through the governance issues to make sure you have the relevant provisions in place.

3. Do employees need to agree to the company being sold to an EOT?

In short, no. There’s no formal obligation to consult employees. In fact, one of the benefits of employee ownership trusts is it gives owners an immediate purchaser and cuts out lengthy sales negotiations. That said, your employees are the future owners of your business, so it’s important to put some careful thought into when and how you involve them in the process. A structured communication plan can aid the transition.

4. Can founders step back straight away?

That’s entirely up to them. With EOTs, founders remain in complete control of when and how they step back. This can be tricky to navigate though as they might need to perform different roles and wear different hats as the business transitions to its new structure. We can steer you through the governance and management issues as they arise.

5. What happens to any profits once the selling shareholders have been paid in full?

We’ll help you with assigning power and responsibility for the distribution of profits when formulating your EOT agreement. Strictly speaking, any profits belong to the employees. But in most cases, we’ll put in provisions to allow company directors to continue to control decisions around what needs to be retained or re-invested in the business. This can also include how profits are distributed to the employee owners. Under EOT rules, an annual, tax-free bonus of up to £3,600 can be paid to each employee.

6. Can the selling shareholders retain a stake?

Yes. To secure tax exemptions, the employee ownership trust must acquire a stake of 51% or more in the company. The remaining 49% can be retained by the existing owners or offered to employees, such as senior management, to buy individually.

7. How do managers manage if employees own the company?

There’s a common misconception that employee-owned companies must act as a co-operative with every decision hanging on the outcome of an employee vote. This isn’t the case. Day to day, business as usual can continue relatively uninterrupted with directors and managers free to manage the business of the company as they always have. All that changes is they’re now accountable to the trust rather than individual owners.

 

Employees benefits

1. What is the financial benefit to employees?

Initially, the EOT will use any profits to repay the remaining purchase price it owes to the shareholders. Consequently, in the early years, there’s usually little direct financial benefit on offer for employees. Once the debt to former owners is repaid, EOTs can start paying bonuses to employees with up to £3,600 per year exempt from income tax.

2. Do employees hold shares after a sale to an EOT?

With all employee shares held collectively in the trust, shares aren’t registered directly to the individuals. With a more traditional employee ownership arrangement, say a management buy-out, employees hold the shares in their own names. Some companies opt for a hybrid combining indirect and direct share ownership.

We can talk you through what might work best for you, but a good place to start is to read our employee ownership guide.

3. Can senior managers be incentivised with shares?

Share schemes are an attractive and cost-effective way of motivating your management team. And there’s nothing in the rules governing employee ownership trusts to stop you rewarding your employees with an additional slice of the pie. Most traditional share incentive schemes can be combined with the tax beneficial employee share schemes available to a company under EOT ownership.

4. Can certain employees be remunerated differently to others?

The business is free to remunerate all employees how it thinks fit, whether that’s through salary, bonuses or otherwise. EOT status allows the award of a voluntary income tax-free, annual bonus to each employee of up to £3600. To qualify for the tax exemption, bonuses must be offered to everyone on the same terms. It is possible, however, to differentiate on the basis of salary, length of service or hours worked. An add-on bonus can also be paid under a separate, taxable profit share plan.

We can help you navigate EOT bonus compliance. But first, if you would like to compare the benefits of an EOT compared to other employee-ownership structures, read our employee ownership guide

Could employee ownership be the future for your company?

If you’re considering adding your company to the 1,000 plus employee-owned businesses in the UK, you’ll first need to evaluate which form of employee ownership works for you. In our employee ownership guide we compare the direct, indirect and hybrid models.  And when you’re ready to talk, our employee ownership experts can guide you through your options, so you choose the right structure for the future of your business.